This is the 2026 refresh of the heat-pump SCOP comparison. The current focus is the 5–6kW range (suitable for a well-insulated ~4–5kW-demand property), but the table is now a single filterable master table driven from a shared dataset, so larger outputs can be added over time — use the search box and the kW column to filter/sort.

The data now lives in _data/heat_pumps.yml as a clean single source of truth, so figures can be de-duplicated, re-ranked and checked by tooling rather than hand-edited in the table.

Criteria / methodology (unchanged from the 2024 table):

  • Target property demand ~4–5kW; units may cycle if oversized (8kW+).
  • EN 14511/14825 Average Climate. Low temp = 35°C, Medium = 45°C, High = 55°C.
  • Ordered by SCOP@35°C where higher is better; ambiguous ranks fall back to 45°C then 55°C (we prefer mild-weather performance which gives greater yearly SCOP).
  • MCS Product Database figures are the source of truth and replace datasheet figures where they differ — see MCS Product Directory.
  • Where a model has no MCS certification, published manufacturer/datasheet figures are used instead and flagged 💔 (unverified). Note many manufacturers publish only COP, not the SCOP@35/45/55 trio, so some newly launched models show no SCOP until they are MCS-certified.
  • Sound ErP is the outdoor sound power on the EU energy label (EN 12102, rated conditions) and is the like-for-like noise comparison. Sound Max is the manufacturer’s stated maximum, which many brands do not publish and whose test conditions vary, so compare it loosely.
  • A * on SCOP@45°C means it was estimated as mean(35,55) because the datasheet omitted it (a conservative underestimate).

Status column legend

Badge Meaning
💎 Datasheet matches MCS-verified figures
📗 MCS-only or a close match to datasheet
📘 MCS present but not close to datasheet (MCS used) — hover the ds≠ marker for datasheet claims
💔 Not validated / unknown — may be mis-ranked

MCS verified, Datasheet only and Rumoured / no data in the Status column are searchable terms — type one into the search box to isolate that confidence tier.

# Make/Model kW SCOP@35°C SCOP@45°C SCOP@55°C Gas Status MCS Cert. Sound ErP (dBA) Sound Max (dBA) Wall Date Valid Links
1 Lambda EU08L 8kW 8 5.66 5.07* 4.48 R290 💔 Datasheet only — 42 56 ✖ 2024-12 site datasheet
2 Ovum AC208P 8 5.53 4.89* 4.0 R290 💔 Datasheet only — 41 54.5 ✖ 2024-07 site datasheet
3 LG ThermaV HM093HF 9kW 9 5.04 3.74 3.75 R290 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W0831_04 49 — ✖ 2024-01 site
4 EBac H1A05WG-GB 5kW 5 4.91 4.38 3.96 R32 💎 MCS verified HP0369/01 — — 👍 2024-02 site datasheet
5 Nibe F2050-6 6 4.87 4.07 3.46 R32 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 012-C700141 53 62 ✖ — datasheet
6 Vaillant aroTHERM pro 5kW (VWL 55/7.1 A S2) 5 4.86 4.22 3.58 R290 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W1212_01 49 57.7 ? 2026-10 site datasheet
7 Samsung Gen7 5kW 5 4.84 4.14 3.43 R290 💎 MCS verified 011-1W0686_2 55 — ✖ — datasheet
8 Vaillant aroTHERM plus 5kW (VWL 55/8.1 A) 5 4.83 4.24* 3.65 R290 💔 Datasheet only — 44 55.6 ? 2025-09 site datasheet brochure
9 Viessmann Vitocal 200-A ie 06 6 4.79 4.09 3.71 R290 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W1300_01 48 56 ? 2026-10 site datasheet brochure
10 Baxi 5kW 5 4.77 4.06 3.39 R32 💎 MCS verified HP0033/10 58 — ✖ — site
11 Stiebel Eltron WPL-A 07 7 4.66 4.21 3.69 R454C 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W0393_02 48 59 ✖ 2024 site datasheet
12 Aira 6kW 1.0 6 4.62 4.1 3.58 R290 📗 MCS verified HP0372/06 57 — ✖ 2024-03 datasheet
13 Bosch CS5800iAW 5kW 5 4.53 3.9 3.28 R290 📘 MCS verified ds≠ HP0329/06 42 53 ✖ — site
14 Viessmann Vitocal 151.A06 6 4.53 4.03 3.61 R290 📗 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W0590_06 51 58 👍 — datasheet brochure
15 Vaillant aroTHERM plus 5kW (VWL 55/6 A) 5 4.48 3.77 3.06 R290 💎 MCS verified KIWA 00016/018HP 54 — 👍 — site datasheet
16 Daikin Altherma 4kW 4 4.43 3.72 3.2 R32 📗 MCS verified ds≠ 011-1W0527_3 58 — ? — site
17 Mitsubishi Ecodan R290 5 4.42 3.9 3.53 R290 📘 MCS verified ds≠ 037-0135-23-1 53 — 👍 — datasheet
18 Ideal Logic Air 5kW 5 4.39 3.83 3.06 R32 📘 MCS verified ds≠ KIWA 00027/023 HP 52 — ✖ 2023-06 site
19 Ecoforest ecoAIR+ 230 (6-24kW) 6 4.38 3.49 3.11 R290 📗 MCS verified 011-1W0921_6 67 — ✖ 2024-10 site
20 Octopus Cosy 6 6 3.98 3.36 3.06 R290 📗 MCS verified HP0255/03 58 — ✖ 2024-05 site MCS
– Grant Aerona 290 (R290) 6 — — — R290 💔 Rumoured / no data — 52 — ✖ — site datasheet
– Panasonic Aquarea L R290 5kW (WH-WDG05LE5) 5 — — — R290 💔 Rumoured / no data — 52 — ✖ 2025 site brochure
– Warmflow Zeno R290 AS01 (3-9kW) 9 — — — R290 💔 Rumoured / no data — 60 — ✖ — site datasheet
– CTC Ecoair 700M 7 — — — R290 💔 Rumoured / no data — 46 — ? 2024-03 site
– Wondrwall DR-HP-006-UK 6 — — — R290 💔 Rumoured / no data — 60 — ? 2024-03 site datasheet

Notes:

  • Figures are refreshed from the MCS Product Database using tools/fetch_mcs.py; links are validated with tools/check_links.py (see tools/README.md).
  • The older 2024 5kW table is retained for history.

ToDo / research backlog:

  • Cross-check the ErP-derived SCOP for the Vaillant aroTHERM plus /8.1 against its MCS entry and promote it from 💔.
  • Confirm SCOP + MCS certs for newly announced 2025/26 models and move them from Rumoured / no data up into a verified tier as figures are published.